October:
Well, here we are two months in to the school year, and might I add it's been a terrific start! This month we analyzed two poems, My Fathers Song, and Promises Like Pie Crust. The remainder of our time was spent making practice MC tests, analyzing Death Of a Salesman, oh and I mustn't forget...eating pie! (My personal favorite!)My Fathers Song:
Analyzing My Fathers Song has brought even more confidence to my ability to analyze and break down poems. As always, the poem seems difficult at first but once you begin to break it apart piece by piece, it's not so bad. The poem dealt with a story, one dealing with several generations of fathers, sons, grandpas etc. and the importance of tight knit relationships between males. Although this poem was great, I much preferred "Promises like Pie-Crust." It seemed as if in "My Fathers Song," our class didn't make as much progress as I'd hoped. I still feel as if we could have dug deeper.Promises Like Pie-Crust:
As for this poem, I quite enjoyed myself during these couple days of discussion. While the first day we had a sub, a rather interesting one... to say the least, we were able to make basic conclusions about the poem declaring that promises are often empty, and recognizing the rhyme scheme right off the bat. However, given that half the class was missing, I don't feel as if this class hour was as productive as it could have been, particularly, when the sub went off on his Arizona rant, and we on our favorite pie rant. Well anyways, that's a separate issue. The second day we filled the class in on the poem, and were able to conclude that past experiences may cause one to be jaded toward love, although love does not necessarily determine ones happiness. My very favorite part of this break down of this poem was that we got to eat pie made by the one and only Max (Thanks Max!) Also, it was delicious. Well, enough of that, onto a more bitter subject... DOS...
Death of a Salesman:
Death of a Salesman was a perplexing novel. Although watching it first made the book much more clear, I still found it difficult to follow the jumps from present to past. As we discussed in class, Willy Loman has got to be one of the most unlikable characters in the history of literature. (in my personal opinion) Although I understand the counterargument, it seems as if Willy is more cowardly than he is brave for giving up his life for a measly some of money. I mean really, is killing yourself more prideful than asking for a hand in life? To me, the answer is no. One thing I like about DOS relative to the American Dream is the controversy in the novel. I find it interesting listening to peoples different points of view on issues such as is Willy Loman likable? or perhaps Could Bif and Happy really have prevented Willy's death? Did they want to? I hope to dive further into discussion about these particular questions. Despite these questions, we undoubtedly have made some really great comparisons, particularly between the relations of characters, and the story of Trolius and Cressida.
Overall, I am really enjoying AP Literature! I still feel I need some serious work on my analyzing of poems, but I must say, I have from last month. I also enjoyed writing a mock MC test. It helped me see the testing process from a different perspective, making me more confident in what to look for and also what NOT to look for. As for other things that I still need to work on include taking the MC tests, and I'd love to give another whack at an essay.
Well, farewell team members...until next month!
Hi Alex,
ReplyDeleteI, like you, gained a lot more confidence in analyzing poetry after our analysis of My Father's Song and Promises Like Pie Crusts. I also enjoyed reading and analyzing Promises Like Pie Crusts - despite not getting to eat pie - possibly because its topic was more relatable to us. I wished you would've gone into more literary depth into your feelings on your class's analyses of the poems (although I did a bad job of this... so I really shouldn't be saying anything). Great analysis on Death of a Salesman! Your class discussed topics our class never touched - i.e. "Could Bif and Happy really have prevented Willy's death? Did they want to?" What did you conclude? Wow, that's great that your class made that connection (I've never even heard of the story of Trolius and Cressida) - it seems as though your class had quality discussions on DOS. Awesome response, Alex!
Great job covering the material and reflecting on its significance to you--I would like to see a bit more connecting of the material to experiences (academic and otherwise) from outside of this course.
ReplyDeleteAlex,
ReplyDeleteThe organization and format of your post is clear and easy to follow. You do a good job of laying out a couple of the subjects that we covered. Your response to the course material also comes out, and your reflection on the material is clear and sincere. However, you seem to be missing some material, such as the multiple choice practice that we worked on. Though the point of the Response to Course Material is not to catalog everything we did in class, you still do not want to leave anything out.
I know that our class came to the conclusion that "Promises Like Pie Crust" is about a speaker that was jaded about love, and that love does not determine one's happiness, but I am just curious if that was what the poem was all about. After all, its title is "Promises Like Pie Crust", not "Love Like Pie Crust". Maybe it has a bit to do with promises and how binding oneself to promises may not be the best option; after all, the speaker does refer to shackles a lot when speaking about promises. So the poem may not just be a sort of rejection letter.
Good job on your post.
Alex,
ReplyDeleteI like the way you organized this response. It's clear and makes it easy for me to follow your thought process. You mentioned everything we learned and gave your opinions as to each of them, giving me a clear understanding of how you stood in the subjects we've covered. I think it's good you compared The American Dream with DOS, as I did as well, because I believe that comparison is the greatest way to understand a piece of literature. I do wish that more of your response to Promises Like Pie-crust was about the poem itself and the DIDLS the author used rather than your classes struggle when you had a sub and the delicious pie you ate (although I am jealous and it was entertaining to read). So, next time, include both, but more of the analyzing. Well done!