Thursday, December 19, 2013

Response to Course Material: 12/22/13

Well, here we are, another month passed, this one packed full with HAMLET HAMLET and more HAMLET! And nothing else. For the most part. (Not that I'm complaining) For these past few weeks we've been finishing up reading Hamlet, watching clips on different interpretations of Hamlet, and of course, discussing!

Finishing Hamlet: 
I must admit I was quite relieved when we (finally!) finished Hamlet. When page 830 rolled around, I thought this can't be it! I don't understand!!! Since then my confusions have been cleared up, for the most part. I found the ending of Hamlet to be very interesting, I certainly did not predict the whole scheme with the poison and how quickly everyone was offed. Overall, I liked the book. Didn't love it, but also didn't hate it. Though I must admit, the more we dive into the finer details of the book, the more entertaining it's becoming! 

Movies: 
1.) Branagh version- It was weird seeing Hamlet in film for the first time. It definitely helped clarify a lot of things, as I was still a bit confused on basic plot due to the difficulty of Shakespeare, (in my opinion). One interesting thing from this version was the ghost and its symbolism for hell. This was an interesting take, and answered one of the essential questions of Hamlet. Another interesting feature of this film was that there was no real indication of a possible relationship between Hamlet and Horatio. I really enjoyed the casting of Gertrude and Claudius, they were exactly how I imagined both in looks and personality. 

2.)  Tennant version- I didn't like this version very much. Hamlet was absolutely nuts, prancing around like a little boy. Although I did like their showing of Hamlet's immaturity. In this version Ophelia was also completely mad, an interesting take as one of the main questions of Hamlet is "Is Hamlet actually crazy or just pretending?" However, it was super neat that the director had characters look into the camera, suggesting people are always watching each other, and everyone knows it. 

3.) Jacobi version- A main difference I remember in this version is the implication of incest between Gertrude and Hamlet. This was the first film to hint at it, and it was a very interesting route to take. He basically humps Gertrude on the bed. Overall, I didn't like this version as much. Hamlet didn't do as good of a job in my opinion. 

4.) Hawk version- This was a very creative version of Hamlet. Being set in the modern time, I found this version much easier to understand. However, it certainly went for movie entertainment rather than sticking to the original text. I didn't like all the cuts they made. It was interesting that in the famous scene with Hamlet and Ophelia, Hamlet was much more sweet, even kissing her once. 

5.) Oliver version- This was, surprisingly, my favorite version of Hamlet. Although I had my doubts, based by  the black and white film, I really enjoyed the casting of both Hamlet and Ophelia. The ending was fun to watch, the sword fight was intense, and overall this version followed pretty closely to the text

Annotations: 
Annotating Hamlet took a LOT longer than I expected. However, it was very helpful. I could better see the role religion plays in the text, and the fact that Hamlet could be a symbol for Jesus/The Devil. One thing I noticed was the repetition of the word "pregnant," which I believe confirms that Ophelia was pregnant. I'm interested in seeing the other aspects people drew from their annotations. 

Discussion: 
So far, I feel like our discussion has been going quite well. On the first day we discovered the whole Devil/Angel symbolism. I liked our discussion today on the essay about the interpretations of Hamlet and how they've changed over time. Some of our class really liked the article, while others did not. I thought the author made some interesting points, but I feel like he had a rather critical view on our generation. In my opinion, there is no right or wrong interpretation. Just as we saw with Bohonnon and the African tribe, everyone sees things differently based on their background. We shouldn't have to change our view to fit what the original interpretation was. But maybe that's just me.

Outside of class references: 
Okay...this might seem silly. But, I couldn't help but think of one of my neighbors (who's a 7 year old boy) and his similarities between him and Hamlet. My neighbor, (*I'll call him David) is very angsty, immature, and doesn't know how to express his emotions properly. This reminded me so much of Hamlet, and his lack of maturity. 




Sunday, December 15, 2013

Open Prompt 2009: 3C

Student 3C: 

This response was.......interesting. This may sound harsh, but this writer sounded like an 8th grader. The writing was unsophisticated and sometimes strayed from the topic. For example, after the thesis discussing that the machete represents a higher level of power, he/she (randomly) says "and the man who carried it was intimidating." I'm not really sure that intimidation and power have a whole lot in common, but maybe that's just me. At times, the writer was contradicting. She uses an example of a battle, representing the power of the machete carrier. However, in her last sentence she adds "although the white men won the battle in the end." I'm not exactly sure why she would include this as it completely counteracts her argument. Despite these errors, the structure of her response was well done, and she made some good arguments. While the AP grader gave this response a 4, I would probably give it a 3 instead, because of it's contradictory statements and often unsophisticated writing. 

Open Prompt: 2009 Student 3B

Student 3B: 

This student does a very good job with her (based on handwriting) symbol, and it's relation to the story. She picked a lampshade and in her thesis states, "...lampshade to symbolize covering up the truth and this symbol exposes Blanche Dubois's obsession with youth.." I thought her thesis statement was specific and well done. This student uses great examples to back up her claim. For example, she states that the protagonist keeps her past from her loving sister and hides truth of why she was fired from family and friends. I have two critiques for this student. One, she tends to focus on plot a little bit too much. At times, I would be so caught up in the plot of the story I would forget about the symbol and it's significance. Secondly, she tends to change her argument, which is presumably why the AP grader gave her a 6. Although her points are valid, sometimes she argues it represents her secret life, while other times it represents her obsession with youth etc. As for the AP graders response, I'm curious as to why they awarded this student a 6. They did not make a single critique. I feel this student deserves a 7 because she makes strong warranted arguments. 

Open Prompt 2009: Student 3A

Student 3A: 

This student was asked to pick a symbol and relate it to theme/bigger picture. She/He does a terrific job identifying a symbol, and backing it up with warrants and evidence from the play. Although the AP grader said their thesis was weak, I didn't think it was too bad. He/She wrote, "..Henrick Iben uses an overarching symbol of a wild duck in order to highlight the events and development of characters throughout." Although I don't think its 100 top notch, I still think it's pretty good. At first, I was confused why the writer spent so much time summarizing the characters of the play, but it soon became evident as this student was arguing the wild duck and its representation of the family relationships. This student did a great job providing evidence from the play. He/She describes one example, the fact that a main character killed himself instead of the duck, because he couldn't stand to part with the duck. The AP grader makes some great points in their response. They touch on the fact that this is a very sophisticated and structured response, and I couldn't agree more. Overall, I thought this student did a textbook job, and I honestly can't find many faults. For this reason, I feel strongly that this student deserves a 9.

Sunday, December 8, 2013

Closed Reading 12/8/13

                                                Who Says Math Has to Be Boring? 
http://www.nytimes.com/2013/12/08/opinion/sunday/who-says-math-has-to-be-boring.html?ref=opinion 

      This article discusses the decline in high school graduates interest in math and science, and jobs involving these subjects. The editorial board argues that these core subjects should be restructured and made more exciting, in hopes to appeal to students. The usage of extensive details, specific language, and syntax prove this emphasize the lack of interest by students, and stress the necessity of revamping these core subjects.

      The editorial board uses large amounts of details to emphasize the lack of interest in math and science and related job fields. According to this article, "90 percent of students say they are not interested in a career or college major involving science, technology, engineering, or math." Right off the bat we are struck by the large amount of students who are so uninterested. The first thought is What can be done about this? Additionally, the article states, "Within five years, there will be 2.4 million STEM (Science, technology, engineering, and math) openings." This shortly follows the first statistic included above. The reason for this, is to show the large gap that is likely to occur, that being, lack of interest but a lot of jobs available. The usage of details is so significant because it drives home the thesis. Readers think, Wow! That's a big number, maybe I should explore this field. These thoughts accomplish the authors main intention, to influence students to get involved in math and science related fields. 

    Specific language is used to over emphasize the lack of interest in Math and Science. For example, the article reports that many students become discouraged and think they are "no good at math." This further shows reasoning for why students are lacking interest, and how unappealing math and science classes are. The authors uses this language in hopes to connect directly with the readers. When a reader sees that detail, they may be thinking, yeah that totally me! This sets up perfectly for a rebuddle. 

     Lastly, syntax plays a key role in expressing their views. The editorial board uses sentence interrupters such as "The number of students who want to pursue engineering or computer science jobs is actually falling, precipitously, at just the moment when the need for workers is soaring. Although the point still would have gotten across without the interrupter, the word precipitously emphasizes that this is not just a small problem, but rather a large and dramatic one. By adding the interrupter, the rate of falling is exaggerated, making students feel personally obligated to make up for these statistics. In addition, the writers purposely listed out all the "usual" courses taken by high school students. The list is extensive, and boring, and helps to demonstrated the unpleasing factor of these courses, and why they may be a factor to the lack of students going into science and math related fields. 

     The details included, the language used, and the syntax all make this article one big bash fest on our education system, particularly the lack of excitement in the math and science areas. The usage of literary techniques helps instill the idea that our education system is BORING and goes on to argue what can be done about it.