http://articles.washingtonpost.com/2012-09-21/opinions/35495036_1_marriage-law-civil-unions-gay-marriage
Doug Mainwaring, a journalist for the Washington Post, discusses his opinion on the idea of gay marriage in his article, Why I oppose gay marriage. Throughout this opinion piece Mainwaring uses diction, syntax, and detail to strengthen his argument, informing readers on his perspective on the issue of gay marriage.
Reading through the article for the first time, readers are struck by the word choice Mainwaring used. Mainwaring uses the term "immutable" to describe the said firmness of male-female marriages. This demonstrates to readers that the idea of a male-female marriage should not be tampered with. He futhur emphasizes his point using "traditional," a word that seems to appeal to many. As many people dislike change, the word traditional strikes out as a synonym for comfortable. When readers think of traditional they probably think of happy traditions, such as cooking turkey on thanksgiving. This word in itself has a positive connotation associated with it.
The usage of syntax throughout the opinion piece is apparent. Right from the get go, this is evident, as seen in the title. The title bluntly states, "Why I oppose gay marriage." Mainwaring did this to highlight exactly what it was he was arguing, likely so readers wouldn't forget it. In addition to that, it's short and to the point. Short sentences are used to emphasize a point and sometimes to create suspense. And it surely worked. Readers are drawn in from the title from the get go.
Last, but certainly not least, Mainwaring uses details to emphasize his disagreement over gay marriage. He starts his article off with great detail on an anti-gay marriage petition that traveled around. He lists of facts and statistics of how many signed off on it, claiming that, " While only 56,550 certified signatures were necessary to get the measure on ballot, more than 160,000 were collected. These numbers struck out to me as a reader. It makes people question if maybe gay marriage isn't such a good thing after all. Another striking piece of detail Mainwaring included was his confession that, "I am gay." He uses this technique to show readers that even he, a gay man, is not supportive of gay marriage. Surely, this makes you wonder.
Overall, Mainwaring did a great job using techniques to get his message across to readers. As an opinion journalist, Mainwaring uses diction, syntax, and details to prove his opposition toward gay marriage.
Alex,
ReplyDeleteHoly cow! He's gay but he's against gay marriage? What? I have never heard an opinion such as his. When he said that, I was shocked to my toes. Definitely shocking. And it's an example of syntax. This short sentence stands out. It's so abrupt it's like one of those annoying billboards covered with a million gazillion fluorescent lights. It's...no words. Way too much. Wow. In your syntax paragraph, I'm not exactly sure that syntax covers what you are quoting. Syntax is more about the punctuation and the sentence structuring, right? The intransitive and transitive verbs? Present and past tense? Maybe since the title is strong and shorter in length it immediately catches a reader's eye? What part of syntax does this title fall under? Lastly, the first person observation. No worries, I did this too but since we have to write analytically, it is important to address only the paper and feelings in a general "what everyone else can feel" kind of way.
Alex,
ReplyDeleteThis article is so crazy. I can't believe that he is gay but against gay marriage. I can't imagine why any who is gay would not want gay marriage to be legal. I thought your detail and diction paragraphs were great. You did a nice job of using quotes from the article to support your statements. I also really liked your quote you used in your detail paragraph. It was a great example since it had such specific numbers. I was also just a little confused about the syntax. I just wasn't sure what technique you were talking about. Just do a little more explaining and then this essay will be perfect! You did a really nice job of organizing all your ideas into a well-written essay though. Great job on this close reading!
Alex,
ReplyDeleteOverall great work on this essay; your first body paragraph, the one regarding word choice, was especially strong and used ample evidence from the text to get its point across. However, your second paragraph on syntax seemed to blend a bit with the literary device of language. What I mean is that several of the examples you provided in backing up your claim related more to the author's use of language or word choice as opposed to syntax. Syntax typically relates to sentence structure and punctuation rather than the specific words or phrases an author uses to prove a point. I could be wrong, of course, that was just an observation. Your details paragraph was well done as well, and your textual evidence related well to the points you were trying to convey. The voice you use in your writing is very accessible too, so I commend you for that. Excellent work!