Sunday, February 16, 2014

Response to Course Material

Well, it's been quite a short month for me, due to the fact that I was away at 7th grade camp for a solid week of our new semester.

Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead 
Well, seeing as I was absent for the week we read this I was slightly confused reading the play on my own. I certainly missed Ms.Holmes commentary and breakdown of the plot and characters. I found myself struggling to find meaning with this play, although I can't tell if that's just me, or if truly the play has no meaning. That's sort of what it seemed like after my first read. I felt as if I was watching a cartoon like Tom and Jerry, or dumb and dumber, for that matter. Sure, there's a plot. But, the point? I'm not so sure. Relative to my other Lit classes I can certainly say I've never read anything quite like this. I'm excited to get annotating and make some sense out of this comical play!

Movie
Unfortunately, I also missed the movie the week I was absent. I'm planning on watching it within the next couple of days to help clarify some things. Based on my class discussion there were some pretty key differences between the movie and the play. We questioned whether or not Stoppard was trying to change his original work? Anyways, it'll be very helpful to watch this so I can finally understand what the heck is going on in our class discussions!


Discussion
We've made some good progress (already!) in our breakdown of Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead. Our class came to the conclusion that we're all on a boat. But, only us humans can control the direction of the boat. We broke the play down into 3 layers. Us humans on the top tier, able to control our actions since we aren't in fact in play. The actors of the play, Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead, who are puppets floating about with no purpose, and the players who also have no control over their fate or destiny. I can't help but wonder if Stoppard wanted us to question whether us humans are part of a big "play." It's an interesting theory.

Open Prompt Practice
Well, I can't say I'm too surprised at Holmes reaction to our open prompts. Speaking for myself, I have some SERIOUS work to do! It was way easier to breakdown other students than actually write one of our own. I was super confused as to whether we were supposed to pull quotes and such from our selected work, because I saw a lot of students doing that. I wasn't too sure because I thought it was supposed to be practice for the real deal, which of course we wouldn't have our books/plays for that! The Open Prompt intro practice was certainly helpful but the time constraint was super difficult to manage. I guess it's good practice though for the AP Exam.

All in all, it's been a quick month! I'm looking forward to our class breakdown of Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead, and to see what else this class has in store for us.

Sunday, February 9, 2014

Open Prompt Pt 2: 2004

2004: Critic Roland Barthes has said, "Literature is the question minus the answer." Choose a novel, or play, and, considering Barthes' observation, write an essay in which you analyze a central question the work raises and the extent to which it offers answers. Explain how the authors' treatment of this question affects your understanding of the work as a whole. Avoid mere plot summary.


    In Shakespeare's Hamlet, Shakespeare presents a key question that drives the entire play, that being whether or not Hamlet should avenge his fathers murder. Shakespeare leaves this question hanging until the very last page, where the audience is forced to determine whether Hamlet's final actions were justified. By presenting this question, Shakespeare develops the theme of his play and leaves the audience searching frantically for an answer to the morality of Hamlet's vengeance.
    When Old Hamlet pays Hamlet a visit, he asks Hamlet to avenge his death, by killing his uncle, who is now married to his mother. The plot of the play becomes predictable right then, either Hamlet will kill his uncle, or he will not. By presenting this question up front, Shakespeare keeps the audience on the edges of their seats and puts the audience in Hamlet's shoes, asking would you seek revenge? What the audience does not know is whether Hamlet will go through with it.
      This central question pushes forward as Hamlet's self struggle between usurping from God is just or not. At the end of the play, the only important character left alive is Horatio, also the only one who has not usurped from God or another of greater status or power. Claudius has stolen the crown from his brother, Hamlet has stolen the power from god in terms of Claudius's death. Or has he? Shakespeare presents this question within the central question and leaves it up to the audience to make up their minds on this matter.
     In the final scene, all lay dead besides Horatio. Hamlet has killed Polonius and Claudius. Hamlet has been killed by Laertes. The play ends with Hamlet being carried out of Elsonoire. Contrary to what the audience expected, Shakespeare never completely answers whether or not it was right to kill Claudius. He leaves the question open to the audience, was it his power to take? In this light, Hamlet the play is one giant question. Minus, of course, the answer.