Student A1:
This student deserves an 8, based on the fact that they constructed a well-written essay, drawing logical conclusions, with proper support for their warrants. From the bat, the student states the focus of the two poems, he/she analyzed. The Student notes that these poems deal with the, "...caustic social criticism of the conditions in 18th century London." From the get go, it is clear the student's intent as to what he/she will be proving. As this student continues, he notes both writing styles for each poem, and does a brilliant job comparing and contrasting the two. In addition to this, he notes the ABAB rhyme scheme. One fault in this, is that the student fails to mention the significance of the rhyming, and how it proves his claim. Furthermore, this student continues on to discuss the difference in tone between these two poems, showing his/her thoughtful analysis of elements, and how they supported his conclusions.
Alex,
ReplyDeleteThis is a good analysis on an Open Prompt. I liked how you listed all the pros and cons of the response. Next time, you could try to note more examples of DIDLS and tie that into how the student successfully answered the prompt. You could even mention how the student used style to prove the author's meaning. Overall, though, great analysis on this!
Alex,
ReplyDeleteWhen you write that the student deserves an 8, do you mean that the graders gave the student an 8, or that the student deserves an 8 in your opinion? I am just not clear about that. Like Debra said, you analysis was pretty good, listing the parts of the student's focus that makes the essay so successful. You only have one textual example; unless you add more, you cannot convincingly back up your claims.
Alex,
ReplyDeleteFrom the beginning, you made it clear what you were going to discuss, and then you actually discussed it. Great job, but I think you could've used more evidence. Put some quotes in there, show me how the student didn't mention the significance of the ABAB pattern, or whatever.