Sunday, September 29, 2013

Response to Course Material (September)

     Walking in on the first day of AP Lit, I wasn't quite sure what to expect. Silly me, I thought the desks hadn't been arranged yet. However, I quickly realized the intention of this set up. Firstly, I love the student led discussions. Sure, we've had "discussions" in past lit. classes, but never without a little hint (Okay, big hint) from our teachers, let alone say the word penis is a class discussion. Besides the odd desk set up, I was quite confused as to why we analyzed paintings on the first day. I mean, hello! I thought this was AP LIT! However, it's clear to me now the intent of this. As an introduction of DIDLS, I was perplexed by the conclusions my class drew from a seemingly simple painting. As we furthered our learning of DIDLS, we practiced both verbally analyzing these techniques, as well as by writing. Up to this point, annotating, in my mind, was simply writing "Love this sentence, yipee doo daa!" However, with the practice from class I feel way more confident about the conclusions I am making, beyond the surface of the literature.
      What I've been most pleased with though, is our class discussion on the American Dream. I'm not going to lie, when we first read through the story I was thinking why in the world are we reading this? and  I must admit, I kept thinking, is this about sex? Where as in other lit classes I would have kept quiet, I felt comfortable enough to discuss my observations with the class, where I learned that yes, indeed it is about sex. I find it very interesting the way a body of people can work off each others ideas. While, my thoughts might not be complete, an idea can spark someone else to put the pieces together. We observed this in discovering what grandma signified, "the old dream," and why she seemed to be the only sane one in the play. The best part though, is that even if we didn't completely connect the dots, we got to read some literary critique and reflect upon them. Not only has this helped me develop ideas about the text, it's also taught me how to reflect academically to a piece of critique. 
     Though I have made great progress since the beginning of the year, there are still a couple things I feel I need work on. First of all, I definitely need to freshen up on my literary vocabulary. Secondly, I struggled with the Close Reading analysis we were given on the spot in class. However, I have full faith by the end of this year I'll be a rock star at these two things. 
     Overall, I'd have to say I'm quite pleased at the direction this class is going, especially the fact that it's student- led. I believe this is great preparation for college, and will give us a leg up against others. I'm looking forward to what October has in store. 

Sunday, September 22, 2013

2004 Question 1 Sample Q

     Out of all the responses, this sample needs the most work. I would have to give this student a 3 based on the fact that he/she lacks in depth explanations, quotes, and examples. Although, he/she has the fundamental ideas down, he/she lacks the true meaning behind these ideas, and fails to direct quotes in support of his/her claim. For example, this student simply states "Symbolism is shown by using dark and night, as well as light." Although this assumption is true, it lacks key reasoning as to what the actual symbol is, thus making it unclear to readers. One good thing this student did was comparing and contrasting the two pieces. She makes a valid claim that Frosts poem is acquainted to the night where Dickinsons poem darkness appears with the night. This paired with the students skilled writing abilities and vocabulary usage, I would award this student with a 3, for some elements deserved to be noted in this sample.

2004 Question 1 Sample T

    This student response proved itself to deserve a 7. This Student does a good job in discussing the differentiation of the dark tone between the two pieces. He/She goes on to discuss imagery by using quotes such as "grow accustomed to the Dark." However, this is one of few spots where the student uses quotes to back their warrants. Instead, he/she tends to paraphrase, part of the reason this student does not receive a top score, in my eyes. Although he/she balances time spent on each text well, the writer lacks sophisticated language, and seems to stay on the surface of the meaning of each passage. While meaning, syntax, and imagery are discussed, this student needs to focus on digging deeper, and asking not what tools is the authors using but rather why he/she is using these tools. Because of this flaw, I deem that this student deserves a 7, for their ideas are strong, but their warrants need work.

2004 Question 1 Sample JJ

     After analyzing Student Sample JJ, I have come to the conclusion that this sample deserves the score of an 8. This student starts off strong by mentioning the difference in meaning between the two texts. In addition, he/she notes the tone right off the bat. He/She does a fantastic job quoting the texts in support of her claims. On top of that, he/she dives into both syntax and imagery, by noting phrases such as "larger-darkness," and by describing scenes depicted in the authors works. Not only does he/she give examples of their claims, he/she actually goes one step further and describes the purpose of the usage of tools such as imagery and syntax. One example, includes the writers explanation of the usage of commas. He/She claims that these pauses add suspense and a tentative effect to the story as a whole. One critique of this work is it's lack of  balance in explanation of the two works. While, the student does a terrific job of analyzing Dickinson's work, he/she lacks in depth analysis of Frosts work. Despite this, I would award this student with an 8 because of his/her understanding and explanation of not only the details, but of the passage as a whole. On top of this, he/she not only makes warranted claims, but uses eloquent words in doing so.

Sunday, September 15, 2013

Misbehaving Responsibly

Misbehaving Responsibly with e-cigarettes 
http://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2013/09/12/e-cigarettes-tobacco-fda-regulation-column/2806757/

     The first thing I noticed about Misbehaving Responsibly with e-cigarettes was the comedic tone that Windsor Mann creates. Mann did a fabulous job of posing her opinion, without forcing it upon readers. As I read on, the second thing I noticed was the sophistication of the piece, although it was an opinion essay. Mann both acknowledges and respects the counter opinion. Through diction, imagery, details, language, and syntax, Windsor Mann depicts her opinion, using a comedic tone.

     A few words stuck out to me as I was reading this opinion piece. Two words were new to me, so of course, i looked them up. The first word I came across was obstinacy, meaning stubborn persistence. In this context it's referring to the counter population of the safety of E-cigarettes, and their stubbornness. The second word that I had never heard of was carcinogens. Carcinogens are any substance that tends to produce cancer. This word was being used to describe the argument against E cigarettes. The words of the essay seemed to be colloquial, as if Mann were conversing with the readers in everyday language.

    One particular pattern I noticed as I was reading was Mann's tendency of making fun of society. In her viewpoint teens are going to consume illegal substances, so why not push for the safest kind of illegal substance? I found this comedic. One thing Mann avoids in this passage is directly addressing the negative side effects induced by nicotine and tobacco. She also fails to describe exactly what an E- cigarette is, which I find ironic, given that that's what the whole passage is about.

     Mann makes you believe that she is absolutely right. Although she is not distanced from the essay, it is clear that this is the correct opinion on said subject. Although Windsor uses a comedic tone, her writing still sounds both educated and informative.

     I think the passage as a whole is a symbol for the hilarity of our society. It seems as if Mann is trying to show the world that people now a days are thinking way too much about innocent inventions, such as E- cigarettes. In the essay, E-cigarettes are even compared to "Larry Kings eighth wife, better than the rest." Clearly, Mann is reaching out to the sense of humor of the audience. Once again, demonstrating the use of her comedic tone and mood of this opinion piece.