Sunday, November 24, 2013

Response to Course Material- November 24th

Response to Course Material: 

Fishbowl discussion (DOS): 

After finishing DOS, we began discussion, as usual, except this time it was "fishbowl" format. Admittedly, that was the very first time I had even heard of the set-up, and I must say, I had mixed feelings about it. While I enjoyed hearing from everyone, I disliked being forced to talk about something, at times, I really hadn't formulated an idea or opinion on yet. While, I realize this is part of the learning process, I feel whole group discussions are more effective, and that I learn just as much as I do from fishbowl discussions. In our discussions we talked about the tape recorder, a possible "outlet" to the past, when times were better. We also talked about which character, if any, were too blame for Willy's death. While we never really reached a definite conclusion, I still stand by the idea that it is Willy's own fault, although I see his reasoning for doing so. I found with DOS discussion it was particularly hard to put feelings and sympathy to the side, and instead focus on the play. I found this to be especially true when discussing whether this play is a tragedy or not. While by Miller's definition, it seems to be, relative to every other tragic play/movie/book I have seen and read, it seems not to be. I guess it depends on what you define a "tragedy." 

Century Quilt: 

Next thing we did was analyze and write an essay, well rather two essays, on the Century Quilt. I really enjoyed this poem, and for some reason found it easier than others to break down. Having said that, after analyzing, I can tell my first essay certainly was not deserving of a 9. While I touched on the biracial family, and the idea of the quilt, I completely missed the idea of time, and the fact that their was tension between the two families. My second essay was MUCH stronger. I found it very helpful to rewrite the essay, though I'm sure some classmates were annoyed by this. It helped me to structure my ideas, and see what a "good" essay looks like. I can finally say that i truly think my poem analyzing is improving! Yay! 

Grammar Practice (or something like that): 

We spent a day, which I actually think was only supposed to be half the hour, on breaking down a sentence. I believe the sentence was, "A rowan like a lipsticked girl." Our goal was to re-create the sentence and focus on where the emphasis was. It was interesting to see the difference in meaning of the sentence between "A lipsticked girl, and the girl with lipstick." (Not sure if that was exactly the sentence we re-created, but you get the point.) Overall, I enjoyed this exercise, though it seemed somewhat obvious. 

Mood and Atmosphere Analysis (Picture # 1): 

I really really liked this assignment. It was very helpful to have to only focus on the mood and atmosphere rather than other elements. My class chose to analyze the ship in the cave, or as we liked to call it, "the womb/the birthing cave." Our paragraph turned out very strong. One thing I learned was to focus on what people are doing/ how things are interacting rather than adjectives. 

MC Practice: 

One of the days we had a sub, we spent the whole hour doing MC practice. My group and I found it was much easier than before. We began to realize not to over think things, and that are gut instinct was often right. The thing I like most about this practice is that the answers are provided, and the explanation too. I can say I'm certainly improving at the MC, and I really hope this pays off!

Reading the Hamlet: 

I found reading the Hamlet was very difficult, and very long. Understandably, it's hard to spit the words out. It was very helpful that Ms. Holmes gave us a summary after every scene, because honestly, a lot of the time I was lost. The language back then was very different, and I found it particularly hard to understand what was going on. I'm excited to discuss this play, and clear up some questions  I have. 

Mood and Atmosphere Practice #2: 

The second picture we selected was the 11 businessmen staring off at someone or something. We picked the word tense as our descriptive word, and after a whole hour, and some ADD moments on behalf of our class, we were able to come up with a pretty good paragraph, though I think we could have done better. By this, I mean I think we could have stayed more on task. I think it would be helpful maybe once to do this practice individually. Although I'm all about group activities, I sometimes feel people develop their ideas much quicker than I do and therefore they beat me to all the conclusions my brain is still trying to formulate. It would be nice to see if I could do this on my own. Again, I find this to be a helpful assignment, it really helps for us to put our thoughts in to words, and to use DIDLS to describe mood and atmosphere. 

Well, I hope that's covers everything.... Please let me know if I'm missing anything! It seems this has been the most action packed section of AP Lit so far, and surprisingly, it also went by the fastest! I'm really making some great improvements, and I'm looking forward to discussing the Hamlet! Goodbye for now! 

Sunday, November 17, 2013

Open Prompt: 2004 Question 3

Student U:
I was somewhat disappointed reading this student's essay. Yet again, the Intro was strong and seemed promising. When I finished my first read-through, I continued to scroll down to make sure I didn't miss a page. The students response was very short. This is okay, except for this student failed to analyze, but instead summarized the plot of this novel. The student does, however, make some good claims. He/She describes Okonkwos fight to hold the village together, he/she then ties it back into the thesis. However, he/she could have described more exactly WHY the strength of Okonkwo relates to "how things stay the same." As the grader points out, the essay as a whole is underdeveloped sometimes stopping his/her ideas mid sentence. Despite this, this student is on the right track, just needs to be more analytic rather than summarize. For these reasons, I would agree with the grader and award this student a 3 based on the potential.

Open Prompt: 2004 Question 3

Student J:
The Student's introductory paragraph is promising. It's concise, and the student makes a good argument. Despite this, the student seems to summarize rather than analyze. While the student does use some good examples, such as the hiding of their friendship to king and duke, the student relies on the plot to make his argument for him/her, a technique that is not as effective as his/her argument could be. Having said that, the student does a good job organizing his/her thoughts and ideas, and the structure and writing is well done in regards to diction and syntax. They used short sentences to emphasize things, which I thought was very clever. Because of this, I feel the student deserves a 7. I did not see quite as many flaws as the grader did. The content was there, and he/she discusses the central question of freedom in depth. The only suggestion I can make is for this student to dive in more in his/her analysis. Other than that, the essay is well written and had some great examples to back up their claims.

Open Prompt: 2004 Question 3

Student N1:
Student N starts strong with his/her intro, clearly and concisely stating the thesis and if "this is the best possible world?" He/She goes on to define the novels focus on this central question. He/She uses details and examples to support his argument such as the character asking "Why have I been forced to leave the castle?" One thing The student points out that at the start of the novel the character was set on discovering the "perfect" world, whereas in the end, he is content with the worlds imperfections. The student quotes the main characters answer, "We must tend to our gardens," when asked if he was in the perfect world. The student then goes on to describe how his answer reflects on his journey, and his comfortably with fixing the world little by little. One error I noticed, as the grader pointed out, was the different usage of language/syntax. He/she flip flops between colloquial language and formal language, an error resulting, in my opinion, the score of an 8 rather than a 9, the AP grader gave this student. I personally, just couldn't get past the lack of uniform language. This student really needed to pick colloquial, or formal. (Preferably formal, as this is an academic essay.)

Wednesday, November 13, 2013

Summary and Analysis: Death of A Salesman

Death of a Salesman

Author:
-Arthur Miller (also wrote the Crucible)
Setting:
-1949 (most likely)
-New York City
-Loman household
-Resturant
-Office Building
Plot:
-Willy arrives home from a buisness trip, Linda comforts her husband and his failure to focus on driving.
-Scene switches to Happy and Biff''s room. The men discuss their childhood in the home, and how things have changed.
-As they falll asleep, Willy relives a flashback of the boys in high school before Biffs big football game.
-The flashback ends. Charley comes to play cards with Willy.
-Willy is struck with another flashback. This time, it is a conversation with his brother Ben, who became a succesful buisnessman. Willy missed the oppurtunity to work with Ben.
-Back in "current'" time, Biff approaches Linda about Willys mental state. Linda is very defensive, and lets her frustrations out, blaming Biff himself.
-Willy enters the conversation and blames Biff of not supporting Willy's dream of Biff becoming a salesman.
-Happy enters and suggest him and Biff go into buisness together, calming Willy. He insists they will meet with Bill Oliver the next day.
-End of Act 1
-The second act begins with Willy waking up well rested, comforted by the fact that his sons are striving to be buisnessmen.
-Willy asks howard if he can have a permanant, non-traveling position.
-Howard instead, insists Willy takes some time off, essentially firing him.
-Willy flashbacks to another scene with Ben while he is in the office with Howard.
-When he leaves the office (in real time) he has yet another flashback, this time when Biff recieved a bad math grade.
-He then goes to Charley's office and learns that Bernard has become a succesful, humble, lawyer.
-Charley offers Willy a job, but Willy is too proud to accept the offer.
-He then goes to dinner to meet his boys, hoping for better news.
-Meanwhile, Happy is distracted by a girl at the resturant, showing Happys "ladys-man" tendencies.
-When their Dad arrives, Biff tries to tell Willy that they could not meet with Bill Oliver, because he doesn't remember them. (Against Happys advice.) Willy refuses to believe it.
-Willy flashes back to a time where Biff caught him having an affair at a hotel in Boston.
-Willy comes home, buying some seeds on the way. He plants them when he gets home, while talking to an imaginary Ben.
-He confides in "Ben" his plan to earn his family 20,000 dollars of life insurance by committing suicide.
-When the boys arrive home, Linda scolds them for how they have treated Willy.
-Biff goes to Willy to tell him he has failed as a buisnessman and is headed back West.
-The two argue, screaming at eachother. Willy is convinced Biff is trying to "spite" him. Finally, Biff breaksdown in tears, and the two embrace.
-Biff, Happy, and Linda go upstairs to get ready for bed.
-Willy then slips outside and kills himself with the car.
-The last scene is a funeral. Very few people were there.
-THE END:)
Characters:
Willy Loman:
-Main Character
-Many characteristics of a tragic hero
-Just over 60
-Has been working for the same company for 30 years, constantly traveling, resulting in very little success.
-Exhausted from trying to support his family.
-Has mental issues. Constantly drifting from reality, to the past.
Linda Loman:
-Willy's wife
-Always supportive, and unwavering during Willy's episodes.
-Loves her family uncondititionally
-Supports her boys and their buisness ventures.
-Sympathetic to Willys pride
Biff Loman:
-Willy's oldest son; 34 years old
-In high school, he was a star football player.
-Had plans to go to the University Of Virginia, but he flunked math senior year.
-He lost all faith in his father and his ventures, when he caught him having an affair.
-Decides to head out West.
-A constant thief
-Attemps to "make it" in the buisness world to appease his family, although he knows he is not cut out to be a buisnessman.
Happy Loman:
-Youngest of Willy's sons.
-Always agreeable and "happy" as his name suggests.
-Lady's man
Charley:
-Good friend of the Lomans.
-Neighbor
-Constantly offering Willy favors, and jobs.
Bernard:
-Charley's son
-Becomes a succesful lawyer
-Humble
Ben:
-Brother of Willy
-Ventured to Alaska and became a succesfull buisnessman.
-Willys confidant.

Other characters: Howard, unnamed woman, Stanley.

Tone and Style:
-The tone of the work can be described as pessimistic and tragic because of the failures all the characters endure. At times, you could even identify the tone as satircial because he fails at achieving every aspect of "The American Dream."
Miller's style is unique. His characters personalities are demonstrated throught the plot. He works as the hand to the puppets, never to bee seen. He offers no opinions or bias, but shows rather than tells.
Point of View:
-Miller's POV is that the American Dream, and the buisness world can be harmful to society. He demonstrates this throught the families struggles to achieve both. His point of view can be seen most clearly through Biff. Biff is the only character who speaks out about the dangers of a capatilist buisness system.

Imagery:
Miller uses tons of imagery in this play. The loman home is is shown as dark and uninviting because of the broken parts of the house, and the looming shadows of the neighbors apartment buildings, blocking them from the rest of the world. In the past, the setting is described with imagery showing the openness and sunniness of the setting. This shows that the past was a a time of prosper and happiness, while Willy's reality is not.

Symbols:
-Seeds/Nature: The nature referenced in this play is symbolic for freedom. Biff constantly talks about out West and the open fields, where he could work with his hands. Also, Willy is constantly obsessing over planting his seeds in the garden. This is a new sense of hope and freedom, especially becasue Willy always uses his garden as an escape from the events of a play.

-Football/ Trophy: Biffs football career represents the security and safety of the past. trophy symbolizes the culmination and downfall of the Loman's happy lifestyle. During high school, everything was looking up for the family: Willy was doing well in his job, Biff and Happy were successful, promising success in business that would be able to support their parents in old age. These dreams all came crashing down. In Willy's memory, as is clear from all the flashbacks, football was the cause of all this success and the thing he associates with it. Football and the Trophy from the Evan's Field game come to metaphorically be the success of the past.

-Tape Recorder: Represents reality. Throughout the play, Willy refuses to accept many things, such as what happened between him and Biff, and why he is unsuccessful. In the scene with the tape recorder, all masks are stripped away, and the truth is revealed. It can no longer be concealed.

"You can't eat the orange and throw the peel away- a man is not a piece of fruit."- Willy
This line summarizes Arthur Miller's view of the nature of the business world, and more importantly, discusses Willy's downfall.
"After all the highways, and the trains, and the appointments, and the years, you end up worth more dead than alive."-Willy
This is one of the most monumental quotes of the entire play. It ironically foreshadows the plays ending. All Willys hard work and time, will result in a bigger failure, that of death. It also describes his mental state, and how he is no longer sane.
Theme:
Death of a salesman, by Arthur Miller, suggests the the misconception many have about the American Dream, and the economic struggles that result from this push to achieve the dream.
Ironically, the setting takes place in New York, somewhere that you would think would be a haven for the success of the American Dream. However, it is not, as represented through the play. Willy fails over and over again to achieve the American Dream. He doesn't have the perfect family, and he is not succesfull in the buisness world. The title of the play furthur supports this, using a Juxtaposition by placing death, by the word salesman, two contradictory words in their connotations.

Sunday, November 10, 2013

Closed Reading 11/10/13

http://articles.washingtonpost.com/2012-09-21/opinions/35495036_1_marriage-law-civil-unions-gay-marriage

      Doug Mainwaring, a journalist for the Washington Post, discusses his opinion on the idea of gay marriage in his article, Why I oppose gay marriage. Throughout this opinion piece Mainwaring uses diction, syntax, and detail to strengthen his argument, informing readers on his perspective on the issue of gay marriage.
     Reading through the article for the first time, readers are struck by the word choice Mainwaring used. Mainwaring uses the term "immutable" to describe the said firmness of male-female marriages. This demonstrates to readers that the idea of a male-female marriage should not be tampered with. He futhur emphasizes his point using "traditional," a word that seems to appeal to many. As many people dislike change, the word traditional strikes out as a synonym for comfortable. When readers think of traditional they probably think of happy traditions, such as cooking turkey on thanksgiving. This word in itself has a positive connotation associated with it.
     The usage of syntax throughout the opinion piece is apparent. Right from the get go, this is evident, as seen in the title. The title bluntly states, "Why I oppose gay  marriage." Mainwaring did this to highlight exactly what it was he was arguing, likely so readers wouldn't forget it. In addition to that, it's short and to the point. Short sentences are used to emphasize a point and sometimes to create suspense. And it surely worked. Readers are drawn in from the title from the get go.
     Last, but certainly not least, Mainwaring uses details to emphasize his disagreement over gay marriage. He starts his article off with great detail on an anti-gay marriage petition that traveled around. He lists of facts and statistics of how many signed off on it, claiming that, " While only 56,550 certified signatures were necessary to get the measure on ballot, more than 160,000 were collected.  These numbers struck out to me as a reader. It makes people question if maybe gay marriage isn't such a good thing after all. Another striking piece of detail Mainwaring included was his confession that, "I am gay." He uses this technique to show readers that even he, a gay man, is not supportive of gay marriage. Surely, this makes you wonder.
    Overall, Mainwaring did a great job using techniques to get his message across to readers. As an opinion journalist, Mainwaring uses diction, syntax, and details to prove his opposition toward gay marriage.