Sunday, October 27, 2013

Yet another month has past.... Response to Course Material: October

October: 

Well, here we are two months in to the school year, and might I add it's been a terrific start! This month we analyzed two poems, My Fathers Song, and Promises Like Pie Crust. The remainder of our time was spent making practice MC tests, analyzing Death Of a Salesman, oh and I mustn't forget...eating pie! (My personal favorite!)

My Fathers Song: 

Analyzing My Fathers Song has brought even more confidence to my ability to analyze and break down poems. As always, the poem seems difficult at first but once you begin to break it apart piece by piece, it's not so bad. The poem dealt with a story, one dealing with several generations of fathers, sons, grandpas etc. and the importance of tight knit relationships between males. Although this poem was great, I much preferred "Promises like Pie-Crust." It seemed as if in "My Fathers Song," our class didn't make as much progress as I'd hoped. I still feel as if we could have dug deeper.

Promises Like Pie-Crust: 

As for this poem, I quite enjoyed myself during these couple days of discussion. While the first day we had a sub, a rather interesting one... to say the least, we were able to make basic conclusions about the poem declaring that promises are often empty, and recognizing the rhyme scheme right off the bat. However, given that half the class was missing, I don't feel as if this class hour was as productive as it could have been, particularly, when the sub went off on his Arizona rant, and we on our favorite pie rant. Well anyways, that's a separate issue. The second day we filled the class in on the poem, and were able to conclude that past experiences may cause one to be jaded toward love, although love does not necessarily determine ones happiness. My very favorite part of this break down of this poem was that we got to eat pie made by the one and only Max (Thanks Max!) Also, it was delicious. Well, enough of that, onto a more bitter subject... DOS...

Death of a Salesman: 

Death of a Salesman was a perplexing novel. Although watching it first made the book much more clear, I still found it difficult to follow the jumps from present to past. As we discussed in class, Willy Loman has got to be one of the most unlikable characters in the history of literature. (in my personal opinion) Although I understand the counterargument, it seems as if Willy is more cowardly than he is brave for giving up his life for a measly some of money. I mean really, is killing yourself more prideful than asking for a hand in life? To me, the answer is no. One thing I like about DOS relative to the American Dream is the controversy in the novel. I find it interesting listening to peoples different points of view on issues such as is Willy Loman likable? or perhaps Could Bif and Happy really have prevented Willy's death? Did they want to? I hope to dive further into discussion about these particular questions. Despite these questions, we undoubtedly have made some really great comparisons, particularly between the relations of characters, and the story of Trolius and Cressida.  

Overall, I am really enjoying AP Literature! I still feel I need some serious work on my analyzing of poems, but I must say, I have from last month. I also enjoyed writing a mock MC test. It helped me see the testing process from a different perspective, making me more confident in what to look for and also what NOT to look for. As for other things that I still need to work on include taking the MC tests, and I'd love to give another whack at an essay. 

Well, farewell team members...until next month!




Sunday, October 20, 2013

Open Prompt: 2005 Question 1

Student 1C: 

I deem that this student should receive a 3-4. Although the student touches on main ideas, and states the elements used to create an overall meaning, he/she fails to provide an in depth analysis of how these elements relate to the passage as a whole. Along with this, the student's organization of their essay is readable, at best. Although they have an introductory paragraph, their main arguments are mashed into 2 questionable paragraphs. The student does a good job in the first paragraph comparing and contrasting the two poems, even going as far as discussing the two poets tones. However, he failed to identify and describe what these  tones were. Despite this, the student does a great job identifying God's role in each of the poems, and brought in an interesting historical background that helped readers to better understand the poems. For these reasons, the student surely does not deserve a 2, even a 3 may be a bit harsh. With just a little more digging this student may have been well on their way to a 5 or 6. 

Open Prompt: 2005 Question 1

Student B1: 

If I were the grader of this student a solid 7. The first thing I noticed about this students essay was the structure. The student has three separate paragraphs for each of his claims, a intro and a conclusion. This creates clarity for readers. This student starts off by telling us exactly what he/she will address (diction, syntax, and figurative language.) From there, he develops his work based on these claims, noting that informal language is used by the composer (Can't remember the proper word) of this poem. He also describes the abab rhyme scheme, and states that it, "..helps move along readers to understand the lives of suffering" Not only does this student note the rhyme scheme, but he/she also describes its purpose. One last thing I noted the student did well was by making a comparison between black/white, haand night/dark. This seems to be a main idea that the student picked up on well. One critique I have for this student is to not lose the big picture. Although this student does a fantastic job analyzing, and breaking down each element, he/she lacks in depth explanation as to the overall function, and how these elements contribute to it. 

Open Prompt: 2005 Question 1

Student A1:

This student deserves an 8, based on the fact that they constructed a well-written essay, drawing logical conclusions, with proper support for their warrants. From the bat, the student states the focus of the two poems, he/she analyzed. The Student notes that these poems deal with the, "...caustic social criticism of the conditions in 18th century London." From the get go, it is clear the student's intent as to what he/she will be proving. As this student continues, he notes both writing styles for each poem, and does a brilliant job comparing and contrasting the two. In addition to this, he notes the ABAB rhyme scheme. One fault in this, is that the student fails to mention the significance of the rhyming, and how it proves his claim. Furthermore, this student continues on to discuss the difference in tone between these two poems, showing his/her thoughtful analysis of elements, and how they supported his conclusions.


Tuesday, October 15, 2013

The American Dream

The American Dream 
Before I begin, I must admit, that this is not my typical writing format. I ask that you bare with me as I try a format what I believe will be the most concise and efficient method. We'll see how this goes.... 

Author: Edward Albee

Setting: Living room of an quaint apartment in which Mommy, Daddy, and Grandma live.
-Late 1950s/Early 1960s 

Plot: 
-Opens with Mommy and Daddy complaining that "they" are late, although it does not refer to who "they" are. 

-Mommy tells Daddy story of beige/wheat/cream hat, showing the materialism of that era. She also complains that nobody can get "satisfaction," most likely pertaining to sexual satisfaction, or the lack thereof. 

-Meanwhile, Grandma packs up her boxes. It can be assumed these boxes contain the values of the "Old Dream."

-Mrs. Barker ("they") finally arrives. At first no one can remember why she is there (except for Grandma) who shares the story of the bumble and how Mommy and Daddy  mutilated it to (presumably) its death.

-The Young Man arrives, and confides in Grandma that he has been psychologically mutilated, although his exterior appearance is in line with the "New Dream."  It can be assumed that the Young Man is the exterior shell of the bumble. 

-Grandma leaves and goes to sit among the audience. Meanwhile, the Young Man (New Dream) comes in (replacing Old Dream) 

-Mommy and Daddy seem content with the Young Man. (Particularly Mommy, who shows strong signs that incest may occur.)

-Grandma speaks directly to the audience, telling them, “Let’s leave things as they are right now… while everybody’s happy… while everybody’s got what he wants… or everybody’s got what he thinks he wants.  Good night, dears” (127)

Important Characters: 
-Mommy: Mommy is a bossy, and not to mention, emasculating character. She has most control in regards to her relationship with Daddy, and can be described as materialistic and unsatisfied. 

-Daddy: Daddy is gender confused. He has a stronger connection with Grandma than Mommy does, and is often controlled by Mommy. 

-Grandma: Grandma is arguably the only likable character in this play. She is the voice of reason, who thinks realistically while others do not. She is representative of the "Old American Dream," and is the only character who can communicate with the audience. 

-Young man: The Young Man is the twin of the "bumble," or rather, the exterior of the bumble. He is the only other character besides Grandma who is self aware, connecting him and Grandma. 

-Mrs. Baker: Mrs. Baker is the only named character in the novel. She is from the adoption agency and is often referred to as "them" or, when talking about herself, "we."

Narrative Voice: None, the play was filled with dialogue. 

Author Style: 
-POV: Albee writes during the a time where the Theater of the Absurd was on the rise. Because of this, he writes with absurdest elements, although the play as a whole still has classical elements, and can not be classified as theater of the Absurd. 

-Tone: Albee takes on a light tone throughout the play. The characters talk with ease about horrific (sorry, my opinion) things such as mutilation, and incest. However, his tone is humorous to the point where you can't help but question the sanity of the characters.

-Imagery: Albee uses frightening imagery such as when describing the mutilation of the bumble, or the images conjured during the sexual encounters between characters 

-Symbolism: The American Dream is packed full of symbolism. Grandma represents the "Old American Dream," one from the pioneer days where people worked day and night. The Young Man demonstrates the "New American Dream," filled with lack of connection between characters and a materialistic society and the boxes Grandma is constantly bringing up are representative of the values of the Old American Dream. 
Quotes: 
1.)“Well, I guess that just about wraps things up.  I mean, for better or worse, this is a comedy, and I don’t think we’d better go any further.  No, definitely not.  So, let’s leave things as they are right now … while everybody’s happy… while everybody’s got what he wants… or everybody’s got what he thinks he wants.  Good night, dears” (127).

This quote is significant because it shows the significance of Grandmas character. It shows that throughout the entire play Grandma was in control, and had a connection with the audience that no other character had. In addition, it shows that Mommy and Daddy aren't going to be satisfied for long, a commonality of the New Dream.

2.)  "Come on in!" (67). 
Although this is a short quote, it is very important because it backs the idea that Grandma represents the "old dream." Since Grandma is the only one who lets the Young Man in, symbolically, she is the only one who can allow the new dream to take over. It's significant, because later the Young Man enters as Grandma leaves, showing the replacement of the New Dream with the old.

Theme: 
The American Dream has shifted from one of the "pioneer days" marked by hard work, into a New Dream defined by materialism, and the lack of satisfaction and connections between people. 

- Albee uses a satirical tone to show the breakdown in the ideas of the New American Dream, and how absurd it is. 
-His images such as the scene describing the wheat/cream/beige hat depicts an image of materialism and consumerism, a trait of the New Dream. 

-By setting Grandma as Old Dream and Young Man as new dream, their interactions and placement throughout the story show the New Dream replacing the Old. For example, Grandma leaves and the Old Man enters. (New replaces Old.)