Student B1:
If I were the grader of this student a solid 7. The first thing I noticed about this students essay was the structure. The student has three separate paragraphs for each of his claims, a intro and a conclusion. This creates clarity for readers. This student starts off by telling us exactly what he/she will address (diction, syntax, and figurative language.) From there, he develops his work based on these claims, noting that informal language is used by the composer (Can't remember the proper word) of this poem. He also describes the abab rhyme scheme, and states that it, "..helps move along readers to understand the lives of suffering" Not only does this student note the rhyme scheme, but he/she also describes its purpose. One last thing I noted the student did well was by making a comparison between black/white, haand night/dark. This seems to be a main idea that the student picked up on well. One critique I have for this student is to not lose the big picture. Although this student does a fantastic job analyzing, and breaking down each element, he/she lacks in depth explanation as to the overall function, and how these elements contribute to it.
Once again, Alex, great analysis on the Open Prompt response. You really have a great knack for this! I like how you used direct quotations in your analysis - you could even use more. Good job hitting all the main aspects of a good AP Lit essay ("effective composition", "insight and understanding", and "specific support").
ReplyDeleteAlex,
ReplyDeleteYour analysis is pretty clear and straightforward, and you make some pretty solide observations. Though you point out many things that the student did well, such as the attention to the ABAB rhyme scheme, I really would have liked to see some more backing. For example, when you state that the student made a good comparison between black/white and night/dark, you can give an example from the essay. Also, what kept this student back? Prevented the student from getting a 9? Why did the student get a slightly lower grade of 7? I would appreciate it if you also gave details on what may have prevented the student from getting a perfect score.
Just guessing, but I think that the word you are looking for when describing ho the student notices the informal language is "colloquial diction".
A small error, but your begin your post with "If I were a grader of this student a solid 7". Though I know that you meant to put "I would give" between "student" and "a", the error was still jarring. I know that it is not really that important, but I just wanted to point that out.
Alex,
ReplyDeleteI'll start off by saying that you had some errors in spelling and grammar (like Andrew pointed out, at the beginning of your essay). Not that big of a deal since I still understood what you were saying, and I don't even know if I should comment on it, but it is an academic blog and next time try not to do that (not trying to be mean at all, I'm just saying!) Other than that though, very nice job. You did well bringing in textual evidence to support your claim, and I enjoyed your critique at the end.