Sunday, October 20, 2013

Open Prompt: 2005 Question 1

Student 1C: 

I deem that this student should receive a 3-4. Although the student touches on main ideas, and states the elements used to create an overall meaning, he/she fails to provide an in depth analysis of how these elements relate to the passage as a whole. Along with this, the student's organization of their essay is readable, at best. Although they have an introductory paragraph, their main arguments are mashed into 2 questionable paragraphs. The student does a good job in the first paragraph comparing and contrasting the two poems, even going as far as discussing the two poets tones. However, he failed to identify and describe what these  tones were. Despite this, the student does a great job identifying God's role in each of the poems, and brought in an interesting historical background that helped readers to better understand the poems. For these reasons, the student surely does not deserve a 2, even a 3 may be a bit harsh. With just a little more digging this student may have been well on their way to a 5 or 6. 

3 comments:

  1. Again, great analysis. Make sure you keep remembering the magic AP Lit essay question: "How does the author use techniques to create effect and meaning"?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Alex,

    Again, you could give more evidence to back up your claims. I don't doubt what you say; its just that by giving a few examples from the text, you will greatly strengthen your argument. For example, after stating the issues that the student had, you said that the student "does a great job identifying God's role in each of the poems...". How does the student do a great job? What does the student do that makes this connection so good? By giving us an example, you can do a better job showing us these claims.
    Also, is there a document with the graders' responses? You can compare the score you would give with the score they gave, and see what their reasons were.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Alex,
    I like how you mentioned the student's organization and how you found it difficult to follow. However, what was the student's organization, and why was it hard to follow? You should really back these warrants up, so we can understand why you feel the way you do. I think you did a good job of covering all the bases of the student's paper, though. You basically discussed what the student was doing in each of his/her paragraphs, which is good, but look more into the DIDLS the student used. Maybe it can help formulate a better score for the student. Overall, well done, just back up your claims with some evidence!

    ReplyDelete