Student 3A:
This student was asked to pick a symbol and relate it to theme/bigger picture. She/He does a terrific job identifying a symbol, and backing it up with warrants and evidence from the play. Although the AP grader said their thesis was weak, I didn't think it was too bad. He/She wrote, "..Henrick Iben uses an overarching symbol of a wild duck in order to highlight the events and development of characters throughout." Although I don't think its 100 top notch, I still think it's pretty good. At first, I was confused why the writer spent so much time summarizing the characters of the play, but it soon became evident as this student was arguing the wild duck and its representation of the family relationships. This student did a great job providing evidence from the play. He/She describes one example, the fact that a main character killed himself instead of the duck, because he couldn't stand to part with the duck. The AP grader makes some great points in their response. They touch on the fact that this is a very sophisticated and structured response, and I couldn't agree more. Overall, I thought this student did a textbook job, and I honestly can't find many faults. For this reason, I feel strongly that this student deserves a 9.
That thesis was pretty vague, so it doesn't really give the writer much to argue. Realistically, they needed to take a firm stance and relate it to a specific theme, rather than the rather nondescript idea of character development. I, personally, find the relatively fine line between too much and too little plot background to be a little frustrating, but that's one of the major things I hope to work on in the coming months.
ReplyDeleteAlex,
ReplyDeleteThe thesis of a paper is important to having a good paper. However, an essay can still be good with a weak thesis if the information following the thesis is strong. You made great points when critiquing this essay and recognizing that although it may have appeared to be a lot of summarizing, there was a purpose for it and it helped to address the prompt.