Student 3B:
This student does a very good job with her (based on handwriting) symbol, and it's relation to the story. She picked a lampshade and in her thesis states, "...lampshade to symbolize covering up the truth and this symbol exposes Blanche Dubois's obsession with youth.." I thought her thesis statement was specific and well done. This student uses great examples to back up her claim. For example, she states that the protagonist keeps her past from her loving sister and hides truth of why she was fired from family and friends. I have two critiques for this student. One, she tends to focus on plot a little bit too much. At times, I would be so caught up in the plot of the story I would forget about the symbol and it's significance. Secondly, she tends to change her argument, which is presumably why the AP grader gave her a 6. Although her points are valid, sometimes she argues it represents her secret life, while other times it represents her obsession with youth etc. As for the AP graders response, I'm curious as to why they awarded this student a 6. They did not make a single critique. I feel this student deserves a 7 because she makes strong warranted arguments.
I'd assume that the 6 came from the fact that a discrepancy in what the major claim/thesis is presents an issue that is fundamentally damaging to the argument as a whole. The thesis is THE point they must argue and not sticking to it can be pretty severe in terms of hurting effectiveness. From what I've read in other essays, the plot distractions don't tend to impact score too badly unless the writer completely forgets their argument and just delves into plot summary, so it's a bit surprising that they were scored so low.
ReplyDeleteAlex,
ReplyDeleteAs you pointed out, this author had a strong thesis, and a strong thesis is important to a written essay. Also, you pointed out that the author used lots of examples to back up their claims, and this is also very important to a strong essay. Without evidence to back a claim up the paper as a whole would have been very effective, You also did a great job at identifying both the strengths and the weaknesses of this essay, and then coming to a conclusion about what score the essay deserved.