Student 3C:
This response was.......interesting. This may sound harsh, but this writer sounded like an 8th grader. The writing was unsophisticated and sometimes strayed from the topic. For example, after the thesis discussing that the machete represents a higher level of power, he/she (randomly) says "and the man who carried it was intimidating." I'm not really sure that intimidation and power have a whole lot in common, but maybe that's just me. At times, the writer was contradicting. She uses an example of a battle, representing the power of the machete carrier. However, in her last sentence she adds "although the white men won the battle in the end." I'm not exactly sure why she would include this as it completely counteracts her argument. Despite these errors, the structure of her response was well done, and she made some good arguments. While the AP grader gave this response a 4, I would probably give it a 3 instead, because of it's contradictory statements and often unsophisticated writing.
(Responding to each of these, so they'll be a little brief) I can see how the writer would link intimidation and power, and there is a link between them, but, without specifically stating that the two are connected, their argument really isn't clear. This really demonstrates the importance of clearly linking ideas over having an elaborate writing style, since demonstrating knowledge of the text and forming a coherent argument along puts one into the upper scoring brackets. The fact that they even got a 4 shows just how much forming even a low-quality argument that's relevant counts for staying out of the lowest score brackets.
ReplyDeleteAlex,
ReplyDeleteGreat job responding to this student's essay. I really appreciated that you added actually direct quotes from the essay to help back up your points. I think the point you made about intimation and power not being something with a lot in common was great, and the author definitely did not back up that point with any evidence. There was a lot wrong with this essay and agree with your score of 3 over the AP grader's score of 4.