Response to Course Material:
Fishbowl discussion (DOS):
After finishing DOS, we began discussion, as usual, except this time it was "fishbowl" format. Admittedly, that was the very first time I had even heard of the set-up, and I must say, I had mixed feelings about it. While I enjoyed hearing from everyone, I disliked being forced to talk about something, at times, I really hadn't formulated an idea or opinion on yet. While, I realize this is part of the learning process, I feel whole group discussions are more effective, and that I learn just as much as I do from fishbowl discussions. In our discussions we talked about the tape recorder, a possible "outlet" to the past, when times were better. We also talked about which character, if any, were too blame for Willy's death. While we never really reached a definite conclusion, I still stand by the idea that it is Willy's own fault, although I see his reasoning for doing so. I found with DOS discussion it was particularly hard to put feelings and sympathy to the side, and instead focus on the play. I found this to be especially true when discussing whether this play is a tragedy or not. While by Miller's definition, it seems to be, relative to every other tragic play/movie/book I have seen and read, it seems not to be. I guess it depends on what you define a "tragedy."
Century Quilt:
Next thing we did was analyze and write an essay, well rather two essays, on the Century Quilt. I really enjoyed this poem, and for some reason found it easier than others to break down. Having said that, after analyzing, I can tell my first essay certainly was not deserving of a 9. While I touched on the biracial family, and the idea of the quilt, I completely missed the idea of time, and the fact that their was tension between the two families. My second essay was MUCH stronger. I found it very helpful to rewrite the essay, though I'm sure some classmates were annoyed by this. It helped me to structure my ideas, and see what a "good" essay looks like. I can finally say that i truly think my poem analyzing is improving! Yay!
Grammar Practice (or something like that):
We spent a day, which I actually think was only supposed to be half the hour, on breaking down a sentence. I believe the sentence was, "A rowan like a lipsticked girl." Our goal was to re-create the sentence and focus on where the emphasis was. It was interesting to see the difference in meaning of the sentence between "A lipsticked girl, and the girl with lipstick." (Not sure if that was exactly the sentence we re-created, but you get the point.) Overall, I enjoyed this exercise, though it seemed somewhat obvious.
Mood and Atmosphere Analysis (Picture # 1):
I really really liked this assignment. It was very helpful to have to only focus on the mood and atmosphere rather than other elements. My class chose to analyze the ship in the cave, or as we liked to call it, "the womb/the birthing cave." Our paragraph turned out very strong. One thing I learned was to focus on what people are doing/ how things are interacting rather than adjectives.
MC Practice:
One of the days we had a sub, we spent the whole hour doing MC practice. My group and I found it was much easier than before. We began to realize not to over think things, and that are gut instinct was often right. The thing I like most about this practice is that the answers are provided, and the explanation too. I can say I'm certainly improving at the MC, and I really hope this pays off!
Reading the Hamlet:
I found reading the Hamlet was very difficult, and very long. Understandably, it's hard to spit the words out. It was very helpful that Ms. Holmes gave us a summary after every scene, because honestly, a lot of the time I was lost. The language back then was very different, and I found it particularly hard to understand what was going on. I'm excited to discuss this play, and clear up some questions I have.
Mood and Atmosphere Practice #2:
The second picture we selected was the 11 businessmen staring off at someone or something. We picked the word tense as our descriptive word, and after a whole hour, and some ADD moments on behalf of our class, we were able to come up with a pretty good paragraph, though I think we could have done better. By this, I mean I think we could have stayed more on task. I think it would be helpful maybe once to do this practice individually. Although I'm all about group activities, I sometimes feel people develop their ideas much quicker than I do and therefore they beat me to all the conclusions my brain is still trying to formulate. It would be nice to see if I could do this on my own. Again, I find this to be a helpful assignment, it really helps for us to put our thoughts in to words, and to use DIDLS to describe mood and atmosphere.
Well, I hope that's covers everything.... Please let me know if I'm missing anything! It seems this has been the most action packed section of AP Lit so far, and surprisingly, it also went by the fastest! I'm really making some great improvements, and I'm looking forward to discussing the Hamlet! Goodbye for now!
Alex,
ReplyDeleteWell, you certainly addressed every topic that we've covered so far in these last couple of weeks...:) You seem to acknowledge the new info, but I'm interested in hearing more of your thoughts. When you mention that our class could have done better with the mood and atmosphere practice, it felt a tad vague.What techniques could we have used to enhance the structure and meaning in our paragraph? How have you used the course material information in your other classes or in your recreational activities? Other than that, I enjoyed your post and agree with you completely over the difficulty Shakespeare presents in his language. I could use a translation of his intricate diction.
Alex,
ReplyDeleteLike Ludia mentioned you really did a nice job of mentioning everything we have covered in class recently. I know it can be hard to remember all of the activities we go in class, so nice job! I thought you did a pretty good job of responding to the course material and not just summarizing it but I would also love to hear more of your thoughts about everything! I also found Hamlet to be pretty difficult to read. Hopefully as we have more discussions about it we will start to have a better understanding of it. I also agree how my second essay on the Century Quilt was so much better. It was so hard the first time to understand everything and write an essay about it. Overall, nice response!
Alex,
ReplyDeleteIt appears that you covered most of the things we talked about in class quite well, probably much more in depth than I tend to do... So good job on that! I agree that the grammar practice can seem a little obvious at times, but I suppose in the long run focusing on the little things in class will allow us to better interpret the big picture later on in the year and on the AP exam. You explanation on the fishbowl discussions was very complete, and it was interesting to read your ideas on the DOS talks themselves. I think it’s rather useful to keep emotions in mind when interpreting literature; after all, what more can good writing do than make us feel? But I do understand where you’re coming from with the idea of detaching ourselves when deciding if something is truly tragic or not. When we do this it is much earlier to come to a conclusion on that topic. Your thoughts on this were very intriguing!