Sunday, November 17, 2013

Open Prompt: 2004 Question 3

Student N1:
Student N starts strong with his/her intro, clearly and concisely stating the thesis and if "this is the best possible world?" He/She goes on to define the novels focus on this central question. He/She uses details and examples to support his argument such as the character asking "Why have I been forced to leave the castle?" One thing The student points out that at the start of the novel the character was set on discovering the "perfect" world, whereas in the end, he is content with the worlds imperfections. The student quotes the main characters answer, "We must tend to our gardens," when asked if he was in the perfect world. The student then goes on to describe how his answer reflects on his journey, and his comfortably with fixing the world little by little. One error I noticed, as the grader pointed out, was the different usage of language/syntax. He/she flip flops between colloquial language and formal language, an error resulting, in my opinion, the score of an 8 rather than a 9, the AP grader gave this student. I personally, just couldn't get past the lack of uniform language. This student really needed to pick colloquial, or formal. (Preferably formal, as this is an academic essay.)

1 comment:

  1. Alex,
    Bummer for this student. So close to that perfect and most desired score. Excellent quoting here. I appreciated your use of quotes and because you incorporated these brief examples I was able to connect with your observation that this student wrote a near perfect essay. Were there any AP Reader's comments? If so, can you add them in? I think that your thoughts will be further supported and you know, you can argue whether or not you agree with them...plus, most of us want to know why he didn't get that darn 9.

    ReplyDelete