Sunday, November 17, 2013

Open Prompt: 2004 Question 3

Student U:
I was somewhat disappointed reading this student's essay. Yet again, the Intro was strong and seemed promising. When I finished my first read-through, I continued to scroll down to make sure I didn't miss a page. The students response was very short. This is okay, except for this student failed to analyze, but instead summarized the plot of this novel. The student does, however, make some good claims. He/She describes Okonkwos fight to hold the village together, he/she then ties it back into the thesis. However, he/she could have described more exactly WHY the strength of Okonkwo relates to "how things stay the same." As the grader points out, the essay as a whole is underdeveloped sometimes stopping his/her ideas mid sentence. Despite this, this student is on the right track, just needs to be more analytic rather than summarize. For these reasons, I would agree with the grader and award this student a 3 based on the potential.

3 comments:

  1. Alex,
    Ha! Short essays are shocking and mentally terrifying. Who wants to be that person? In response to this post, consider providing examples when you address this student's mistakes. Maybe mention any recommendations that you have for this student.... Also, instead of telling what the good claims are perhaps you can quote these claims and then follow them by explaining how these claims were helpful to the essay's performance. Readers want to see how this student didn't do as well.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Alex,

    I read all your responses and I am just going to respond on this one to make it more concise. I thought you had really nice responses to these essays. It seems like you came to most of the same conclusions as the AP reader did...so that's good! I would just add more quotes to back up your claims. I have been told to do this as well so I am working on it too. We obviously trust that what you're saying is true but when you have quotes it makes your responses rock solid. Other than that these responses were very good! Oh and I also really like you how weren't that harsh in your responses especially to this one. As we know these essays can be pretty hard to write:)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Alex,
    All of your responses to the essays were well written, so great work on that! You made good points in each of them and relating your critiques back to those of the AP graders worked nicely to back up your ideas. Your second and third analysis, though, might have benefited from a bit more textual evidence. It's easy for us to get what you're saying because we have the specific essays to reference as we read through your responses, but adding a few more actual quotes from the passages would likely help the understanding of a reader who didn't have those readily available. The evidence you did use though, especially in your first critique was well chosen. I also like that you went with a neutral tone in your writing; that’s something I struggle with sometimes… Good job! 

    ReplyDelete