Sunday, November 17, 2013

Open Prompt: 2004 Question 3

Student J:
The Student's introductory paragraph is promising. It's concise, and the student makes a good argument. Despite this, the student seems to summarize rather than analyze. While the student does use some good examples, such as the hiding of their friendship to king and duke, the student relies on the plot to make his argument for him/her, a technique that is not as effective as his/her argument could be. Having said that, the student does a good job organizing his/her thoughts and ideas, and the structure and writing is well done in regards to diction and syntax. They used short sentences to emphasize things, which I thought was very clever. Because of this, I feel the student deserves a 7. I did not see quite as many flaws as the grader did. The content was there, and he/she discusses the central question of freedom in depth. The only suggestion I can make is for this student to dive in more in his/her analysis. Other than that, the essay is well written and had some great examples to back up their claims.

1 comment:

  1. Alex,
    Again, quotes. There's nothing particularly wrong about not having them, but they'll help for your readers to also think, yeah I totally agree. What stood out to you in the introductory paragraph. You mention that it was concise, but don't forget you can elaborate. Any particular technique this student used, since you write that the writing and structure is well done? Diction? Syntax? So many questions, sorry.

    ReplyDelete