Sunday, September 22, 2013

2004 Question 1 Sample Q

     Out of all the responses, this sample needs the most work. I would have to give this student a 3 based on the fact that he/she lacks in depth explanations, quotes, and examples. Although, he/she has the fundamental ideas down, he/she lacks the true meaning behind these ideas, and fails to direct quotes in support of his/her claim. For example, this student simply states "Symbolism is shown by using dark and night, as well as light." Although this assumption is true, it lacks key reasoning as to what the actual symbol is, thus making it unclear to readers. One good thing this student did was comparing and contrasting the two pieces. She makes a valid claim that Frosts poem is acquainted to the night where Dickinsons poem darkness appears with the night. This paired with the students skilled writing abilities and vocabulary usage, I would award this student with a 3, for some elements deserved to be noted in this sample.

3 comments:

  1. Alex, I like how you emphasized the importance of using textual evidence to support claims. Even if a student has good ideas, he/she cannot score high without claims. In addition, it's important that you noted the author's faulty reasoning which is comparable to her lack of insight or understanding.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Alex,
    Wow, a three is a harsh score for an essay, I really hope the writer deserved it, and from your analysis it sounds like he or she did. Reading over those poorly written essays gives us a pretty good template for what not to do when you're writing during the actual exam, and I think that's an invaluable resource. I'd rather not end up like 2004 question 1 sample Q writer who doesn't add any depth to his or her analysis and gets a three. I'm shooting for at least a four.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Alex,
    You make an interesting point in this passage: even if the analysis and understanding of a piece is correct, a poor grade is still possible. The most important part of the AP test will be how we support and convey our arguments in a concise and detailed manner. This is why I believe that we can learn more from a poor essay than a successful essay. We can see the flaws a person makes and the objectives of the grader.

    ReplyDelete