Sunday, September 15, 2013

Misbehaving Responsibly

Misbehaving Responsibly with e-cigarettes 
http://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2013/09/12/e-cigarettes-tobacco-fda-regulation-column/2806757/

     The first thing I noticed about Misbehaving Responsibly with e-cigarettes was the comedic tone that Windsor Mann creates. Mann did a fabulous job of posing her opinion, without forcing it upon readers. As I read on, the second thing I noticed was the sophistication of the piece, although it was an opinion essay. Mann both acknowledges and respects the counter opinion. Through diction, imagery, details, language, and syntax, Windsor Mann depicts her opinion, using a comedic tone.

     A few words stuck out to me as I was reading this opinion piece. Two words were new to me, so of course, i looked them up. The first word I came across was obstinacy, meaning stubborn persistence. In this context it's referring to the counter population of the safety of E-cigarettes, and their stubbornness. The second word that I had never heard of was carcinogens. Carcinogens are any substance that tends to produce cancer. This word was being used to describe the argument against E cigarettes. The words of the essay seemed to be colloquial, as if Mann were conversing with the readers in everyday language.

    One particular pattern I noticed as I was reading was Mann's tendency of making fun of society. In her viewpoint teens are going to consume illegal substances, so why not push for the safest kind of illegal substance? I found this comedic. One thing Mann avoids in this passage is directly addressing the negative side effects induced by nicotine and tobacco. She also fails to describe exactly what an E- cigarette is, which I find ironic, given that that's what the whole passage is about.

     Mann makes you believe that she is absolutely right. Although she is not distanced from the essay, it is clear that this is the correct opinion on said subject. Although Windsor uses a comedic tone, her writing still sounds both educated and informative.

     I think the passage as a whole is a symbol for the hilarity of our society. It seems as if Mann is trying to show the world that people now a days are thinking way too much about innocent inventions, such as E- cigarettes. In the essay, E-cigarettes are even compared to "Larry Kings eighth wife, better than the rest." Clearly, Mann is reaching out to the sense of humor of the audience. Once again, demonstrating the use of her comedic tone and mood of this opinion piece.
   

6 comments:

  1. Alex,
    It seems as if you didn't really understand the assignment here, because you brought a lot of your personal opinions into your analysis instead of sticking to the text. Yes, you did conclude that the tone was comical and that she used DIDLS, etc, to achieve this comedy, but your essay was lacking any specific, textual examples. And you also said that Mann's opinion about e-cigarettes was "correct", which in the subjective world of literature and writing is a tough thing to say. The article was an opinion piece, but calling one person's opinion "correct" instead of simply agreeing with it are two different things. Overall, I think you could do better next time. Try and bring in as many examples from the text to support your analysis of the work rather than write about whether or not you agree with the author. Now I'm not saying your writing is bad or anything; in fact, I think you could do quite a bit with the slightly informal, offhand voice you use, but just try and stay on task next time. And if you can't come up with examples to go with all the aspects of DIDLS, don't try and force it. You'll end up at a dead end, a place I've been many a time, and it's no fun over there.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Alex,
    You mentioned that you had some difficulty about this assignment in comments in other blogs and, sorry, it is a bit evident. Oh well, its the worst time is the first time right?
    Anyways, on to the criticism. You did describe the article, albeit not very detailed. My perception about the article was different from what the article was when I clicked the link (though that is actually more of my fault than yours). I noticed that your response then seemed to dive off to a tangent, going from mentioning the literary techniques to defining two words and your opinion of the piece. I know that it is difficult to dive into DIDLS and such, but hey, the assignment is the assignment. You mentioned your response to the article, ask "why words make me feel this way?" "How are the words structured to persuade me to this opinion?" "What does the author do to make this article entertaining and readable?"
    You can do better. Just stretch a little further, and it will be there.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Alex, as the other two above mentioned, I would have liked to have seen more microscopic analysis instead of your own opinions. At this point, you are still reading at the microscopic level. You should ask yourself questions such as, "How did Mann use diction, imagery, details, etc. to create a comedic effect?" Although you did briefly mention diction, you only mentioned your take on it as opposed to how the author used diction to produce meaning/effects she desired. I agree that the article sounded sophisticated, however, this most likely was not the meaning the author was trying to construe. I would recommend first finding the author's intended meaning and then closing in on DIDLS to prove that you correctly interpreted the author's meaning. On a positive note, I once again enjoy your voice in this blog post.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Alex--You got some really great feedback from your peer reviewers, here. I'd like to have seen you use it to rewrite this. They took quite a bit of time to read the article you read and then think about how to coach you so that you could make progress in your work. I'm just about to click through to your October Close Reading post, and I'm hoping that you at least made use of their good advice there....

    ReplyDelete
  5. Oh. You have no October Close Reading. I see. Also, you've removed my comment on your Oct. Response to Course Materials. Since I posted that as part of the grading process, I'll have to reread that post again. Please don't remove anyone's comments on any blog posts.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Oh--my mistake--I see the comment on the Oct Response to Course Materials, sorry. Not sure where I saw the deleted comment.

    ReplyDelete