Sunday, September 22, 2013

2004 Question 1 Sample T

    This student response proved itself to deserve a 7. This Student does a good job in discussing the differentiation of the dark tone between the two pieces. He/She goes on to discuss imagery by using quotes such as "grow accustomed to the Dark." However, this is one of few spots where the student uses quotes to back their warrants. Instead, he/she tends to paraphrase, part of the reason this student does not receive a top score, in my eyes. Although he/she balances time spent on each text well, the writer lacks sophisticated language, and seems to stay on the surface of the meaning of each passage. While meaning, syntax, and imagery are discussed, this student needs to focus on digging deeper, and asking not what tools is the authors using but rather why he/she is using these tools. Because of this flaw, I deem that this student deserves a 7, for their ideas are strong, but their warrants need work.

3 comments:

  1. Once again, a great analysis. Based on your analysis, it seems that the student author needed a reminder of what the fundamental question of all AP Lit essays is: "how does the author use techniques to create effects and meaning?" Also, good job catching whatever irrelevant or ineffective paraphrasing was used.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Alex,
    Here you address a fundamental problem that appears in probably ninety percent of all AP writers' essays: over-summarizing. Holmes should plaster a poster to her wall that gives some grave warning about writing too much about details and less about actual analysis, because it really is everywhere. I saw it quite a bit in the essays I read. But I suppose you give us hope, because you demonstrate that even if you over-summarize a little bit you can still get a mid-high score on an essay. Now I can sleep a little easier tonight.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Alex,
    Yeah, like Drew said: You recognize that the writer just summarized the text and did little analyzing. This is a problem that I think all of us will need to be highly aware of on the test in May. I would like to see what examples of the student's writing that you thought consisted of a "lack [of] sophisticated language" and such, just so we can further analyze the mistakes and blunders of the poor student. The little guinea pigs. Lab rats. Reese monkeys.

    ReplyDelete