Sunday, September 22, 2013

2004 Question 1 Sample JJ

     After analyzing Student Sample JJ, I have come to the conclusion that this sample deserves the score of an 8. This student starts off strong by mentioning the difference in meaning between the two texts. In addition, he/she notes the tone right off the bat. He/She does a fantastic job quoting the texts in support of her claims. On top of that, he/she dives into both syntax and imagery, by noting phrases such as "larger-darkness," and by describing scenes depicted in the authors works. Not only does he/she give examples of their claims, he/she actually goes one step further and describes the purpose of the usage of tools such as imagery and syntax. One example, includes the writers explanation of the usage of commas. He/She claims that these pauses add suspense and a tentative effect to the story as a whole. One critique of this work is it's lack of  balance in explanation of the two works. While, the student does a terrific job of analyzing Dickinson's work, he/she lacks in depth analysis of Frosts work. Despite this, I would award this student with an 8 because of his/her understanding and explanation of not only the details, but of the passage as a whole. On top of this, he/she not only makes warranted claims, but uses eloquent words in doing so.

3 comments:

  1. Great analysis, Alex! Your analysis shows how useful DIDLS will be when writing AP Lit essays. I'm not sure about if an AP Lit essay is ever graded higher based on eloquence of speech, however. Isn't it similar to an AP World essay where you just have to have enough quotes/evidence to support a claim? It was great how you gave so many examples to support your scoring. Maybe next time you could also try discussing organization as well. Thanks for the in-depth post!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Alex,
    Good job in your analysis, I haven't much to say about it, really, other than a reflection of what Debra said. Eloquence of language probably doesn't matter when you're in the thick of writing an AP essay. No AP reader is gonna give you a discounted score because you wrote beautifully and didn't analyse a lick of information, which is something I think we all should consider. Like our good friend Michael Harvey writes in "Nuts and Bolts" concision is more important than cramming in as many big words as possible into a sentence.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Alex,
    Haha, looks like I'm last, so that where was not much left for me to say. Well, what to say...
    You demonstrate a great understanding what makes a good essay a good essay, pointing out the strengths and weaknesses of the writer. You say how the writer not only mentions the literary aspects, but also how they add to the piece. You did a good job. However, I don't want to say you did a bad job (you didn't) but I would appreciate it if you included examples of the good stuff instead of just mentioning them. Good job.

    ReplyDelete