Sunday, March 9, 2014

Open Prompt Part 2: 2005

2005: One of the strongest human drives seems to be the desire for power. Write an essay in which you discuss how a character in a novel or a drama struggles to free himself or herself from the power of others or seeks to gain power over others. Be sure to demonstrate in your essay how the author uses this power struggle to enhance the meaning of the work.

     In Fitzgerald's, Great Gatsby, Jay Gatsby seeks to gain power over Nick Bucchanan and Nick's cousin, Daisy. His struggle for control over the the other characters exemplifies the idea that the original values of the American Dream have disintegrated into more selfish one's such as wealth and power.

     Throughout Fitzgerald's novel, Jay Gatsby, a desperate character, is constantly manipulating Nick and Daisy to gain power and control. When Nick moves in next door to the mysterious Jay Gatsby, Jay seeks immediate interest in Nick Buchannan for a reason which soon becomes clear, his desire for power over Daisy Buchannan. One day, Nick receives a formal invitation to one of Jay Gatsby's lavish parties. As it turns out, the only reason Nick was invited was in hopes that Nick could set Jay up with Nick's cousin, Daisy. In addition to this, Jay takes Nick on numerous adventures where he tells him numerous lies regarding his background, in hopes of gaining control over Nick and not only that, but respect. Throughout the entire novel, Jay Gatsby is chasing after his first love, Daisy Buchannan. He tries to impress Daisy with his wealth and gain control over her, although she's married. However, readers question whether Jay is really in love with Daisy, or whether he is just trying to control her in order to gain power and up his reputation.

      Fitzgerald uses Jay's need to control the other characters as a prime example of the disintegration of the American Dream. The fact that Jay strives for Daisy Buchannan, a rich and beautiful batchelorette, points out the fact that all Jay is looking for is something shallow and superficial, whereas the traditional American Dream has been based off of ideas such as hardwork and dedication. When Jay uses Nick as a ploy to get to Daisy, Fitzgerald was commenting that Americans are no longer kind, friendly, neighbors, rather, they only reach out when they need something.
   
    The Great Gatsby is an American classic. On the surface it seems as if it's a story of failed love, while in reality it's a novel about power and control. Jay is a manipulative character who lives of his control over other characters in order to satisfy his reputation. Because of this, the Great Gatsby can be interpreted as a novel representing the breakdown of the traditional American Dream, being replaced by a materialistic, and shallow dream.



   

2 comments:

  1. Hi Alex,

    First off, just a little thing, but make sure you get the title right of the work of literature you are using. Not a big deal, but it may prejudice your essay grader right from the beginning. It's The Great Gatsby, not just Great Gatsby. Also, you don't have the right character names, which confused me. The character Nick Buchanan doesn't exist. There's Nick Carraway, the narrator, or Tom Buchanan, Daisy's husband. It seemed like you combined both characters in one, although I'm not too sure. I think you're describing Nick, the narrator, but it makes more sense to say that Gatsby was trying to take control of Tom Buchanan, Daisy's husband, since Gatsby was trying to win over Daisy. Also, try to expand your introduction by adding more background detail on the aspect of power in The Great Gatsby. Also, try organizing your supporting paragraphs more logically. Great job with your conclusion, although you might want to mention the thesis in it, as in mention "power" again. Overall, solid points, but you need more logically progression and correct title/character names.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Alex,

    Sadly enough, I have never read the Great Gatsby, nor seen the film like MOST FOLKS, because I have made a promise to myself that I will not ruin the novel for myself by not watching it first. This has been a long-term ride on the strugglebus. But enough of that. The point is that I cannot agree or disagree on any points you make here regarding the novel, however I can tell you that it's a good open prompt essay because you did not just summarize the plot and you keep your loops on your goose from start to finish. You clearly were able to comprehend and to connect the instructions: to "demonstrate in your essay how the author uses this power struggle to enhance the meaning of the work" into your answer.

    ReplyDelete