Sunday, February 9, 2014

Open Prompt Pt 2: 2004

2004: Critic Roland Barthes has said, "Literature is the question minus the answer." Choose a novel, or play, and, considering Barthes' observation, write an essay in which you analyze a central question the work raises and the extent to which it offers answers. Explain how the authors' treatment of this question affects your understanding of the work as a whole. Avoid mere plot summary.


    In Shakespeare's Hamlet, Shakespeare presents a key question that drives the entire play, that being whether or not Hamlet should avenge his fathers murder. Shakespeare leaves this question hanging until the very last page, where the audience is forced to determine whether Hamlet's final actions were justified. By presenting this question, Shakespeare develops the theme of his play and leaves the audience searching frantically for an answer to the morality of Hamlet's vengeance.
    When Old Hamlet pays Hamlet a visit, he asks Hamlet to avenge his death, by killing his uncle, who is now married to his mother. The plot of the play becomes predictable right then, either Hamlet will kill his uncle, or he will not. By presenting this question up front, Shakespeare keeps the audience on the edges of their seats and puts the audience in Hamlet's shoes, asking would you seek revenge? What the audience does not know is whether Hamlet will go through with it.
      This central question pushes forward as Hamlet's self struggle between usurping from God is just or not. At the end of the play, the only important character left alive is Horatio, also the only one who has not usurped from God or another of greater status or power. Claudius has stolen the crown from his brother, Hamlet has stolen the power from god in terms of Claudius's death. Or has he? Shakespeare presents this question within the central question and leaves it up to the audience to make up their minds on this matter.
     In the final scene, all lay dead besides Horatio. Hamlet has killed Polonius and Claudius. Hamlet has been killed by Laertes. The play ends with Hamlet being carried out of Elsonoire. Contrary to what the audience expected, Shakespeare never completely answers whether or not it was right to kill Claudius. He leaves the question open to the audience, was it his power to take? In this light, Hamlet the play is one giant question. Minus, of course, the answer.




4 comments:

  1. Hi Alex,
    Good open prompt, you followed Holmes’s recipe for the introduction and it is a strong introduction. I deviated form it in my second open prompt by accident. You do a good job of answering most of the prompt, but I think you could spend more time on to what extent the play answers this question. You do mention this in the conclusion, but I think spending more time on it will make your open prompt stronger. You had some good evidence from the play to support your essay. I was getting a bit confused between the central question and the other question on the morality of killing Claudius, specifically when they are both discussed in the conclusion. Good job though overall. I also had the same prompt for my open prompt and also used Hamlet.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Alex,
    Overall this was a pretty good essay and did a pretty good job answering all parts of the prompt. To me there seemed to be a slight disconnect between your opening sentence and the second sentence; I thought this essay was going to be talking about whether or not Hamlet would avenge his father and instead it’s about the morality question of the play (this may just be me though and it doesn’t detract from your essay). Another little thing that I’m going to nitpick at is just the phrasing of “usurping from God”. This is really not a big thing but there is something about the phrasing that slightly bothers me as it seems you are combining the two ideas of usurpation and providence. There is good flow to this essay and you did a good job sticking to your thesis and explaining the different aspects of the question you mentioned in your introduction paragraph. The only thing I really would criticize is the question you decided on. It’s not a bad question to address and you did a really good job explaining it, it just seems a little one-dimensional. Overall great post Alex!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Alex,

    This is very strange; did everyone do the same question? And did everyone use Hamlet? Your introduction paragraph is fantastic, and really hits the prompt question on the head without getting too fancy or simple. It was kind of fun to read it and hear you say that Shakespeare left his question “hanging until the very last page,” making me think that you responded incorrectly since the prompt says “the question MINUS the answer.” However, you immediately throw in the real question Shakespeare is asking. I think looping the introduction like this can sometimes help invigorate the brain and wake up the readers a bit more, as it certainly woke mine up. The defense you have for this thesis is strong too, never wavering too far from the point of the essay. Overall, this essay makes me think you’ll do just fine by the time the AP exam rolls around in May. :D

    ReplyDelete
  4. Caitlin, Susheela, and Blake: You aren't paying as close attention as you need to, here, to everything that goes into creating a strong argument. While Alex has chosen a strong topic in response to this prompt and begins to set up a relatively solid introduction, by the time she gets to the last line of the intro, you should already know that she's setting herself up for trouble. The last line of the intro should tell us whether Shakespeare resolves the question of Hamlet's justification in killing Claudius and should also tie that resolution to the play's theme. The expected divisions of this essay would be: explain the question/show the extent to which is is resolved/show why the author has made this choice, thematically. Because the intro is not set up clearly, these elements are mixed throughout the entire essay instead of clearly delineated into separate claims backed up by evidence and warrants. This creates a muddy argument that doesn't really go anywhere.

    ReplyDelete